I like to say that IT often sells the same thing in new pipes. With AI, for me it is the other way round right now: new teamwork in old pipes. The instruments are new; the rules for playing well together are old. I learned part of them in a place you would not expect: for three years I ran a jazz club.
On our AI World Tour a circle closed for me that spans many years. This post is about that.
A sentence on the screen in Shanghai
On 5 November Ryo Lu was on the main stage of AI Engineer Shanghai. He was the founding designer at Cursor and built tools at Notion before that. His talk was called "When we can do anything, do we still know what we want?": when AI makes execution easy, doing more, faster becomes the default, and we lose the time to form ideas of our own. In the middle of the talk this sentence was on the slide, its beginning and end cut off:
… to know who will spot what we've missed, and who can take an idea apart without killing it. Like a jazz ensemble, it's not about everyone playing the most notes, nor is everyone rushing to prove they're the best. One person carries the melody while others listen first, …
I took out my phone and photographed it. The sentence reminded me of two things from long ago.
The evening at the Unterfahrt
The first: at Jazzclub Unterfahrt in Munich I once listened to Professor August-Wilhelm Scheer give a talk. Scheer is a business informatics professor and an enthusiastic jazz saxophonist who, by his own account, plays around 40 concerts a year with various professional bands.
His theme for a long time has been what managers can learn from jazz musicians. In an interview with managerSeminare he put it like this (our translation): "The musicians pay very close attention to each other while playing. They listen well and watch which direction the others are developing in during the piece or with their solo." And further, that in jazz "every musician keeps switching from the role of soloist to that of accompanist and back".
A talk of his on the same theme is on YouTube, recorded at the Scheer City Hub in Saarbrücken with the musician Sebastian Voltz. It was recorded on a different evening from the one I attended; the ideas are the same.
How the circle closes
The second goes back even further. I studied business informatics in Ulm. My professor there came from Scheer's school: she had been a research associate with Prof. Scheer in Saarbrücken.
So I learned the basics from someone out of Scheer's circle. Years later I heard Scheer himself talk about jazz and leadership in a jazz club. And now, at an AI conference in Shanghai, the same picture is on a slide. That moved me more than I wanted to admit.
New teamwork in old pipes
At XALT the whole team now works in one shared agent session: several people, one agent, the same context. Our article on OpenClaw Multiplayer in the enterprise describes how that works. Those are the new instruments. An agent plays a great many notes very fast, all night long if you let it.
The rules that make the playing good are old, though. One person carries the melody; the others listen first. The roles change, just as Scheer describes it for soloist and accompanist. My observation from the last few weeks: the best results came when one person clearly knew what should come out at the end, and the others, people and agents alike, first read what was already there before adding anything. When everyone starts at once, you get noise.
Who spots what we've missed
The part of Ryo Lu's sentence that occupies me most is right at the start: knowing who will spot what we've missed, and who can take an idea apart without killing it. People like that are rare on any team. You recognise them because after their criticism the idea is better, and still alive.
With agents on the team this skill becomes more valuable. An agent quickly delivers a draft that looks good. Someone has to notice what is missing from it and say so in a way that keeps the team going.
What I take from it
I do not want to turn this into rules. These are observations I currently think are right:
- One person carries the melody. For every task it should be clear who holds the goal. That can change, but it should never be unclear.
- Listen first, then play. Before anyone, person or agent, adds something, it pays to look at what is already there.
- Value the people who find the gaps. Whoever takes an idea apart without killing it deserves more credit than whoever delivers the most.
More listening in a louder band
The instruments are getting louder and faster. The old rules are still enough: listen first, leave space, pass the melody on. I learned that in the jazz club, heard it again from Scheer and found it on a slide in Shanghai.



